Why We Idealize Others (And Why It Leads to Hurt)

Have you ever felt that sharp pang of disappointment? That moment when someone, or something, you held in high regard reveals itself to be… well, merely human? Merely real? It’s a familiar ache, a common thread in the tapestry of our lives. We build pedestals, place our hopes and expectations upon them, and then watch, sometimes with shock, sometimes with a slow dawning sadness, as they prove unstable. Disappointment is inevitable, a collision between our inner picture and the often messier external world. It can sting, leaving us feeling frustrated, sad, perhaps even resentful. But within this discomfort lies a profound opportunity – a chance to shed illusions and see with clearer eyes. The crucial part isn't avoiding disappointment, but learning how to meet it, how to process it in a way that fosters growth rather than trapping us in a cycle of searching and discarding.

Why do we even build these pedestals in the first place? Often, it stems from a deep-seated need within our minds to maintain a sense of order and consistency. We crave a world that makes sense, where things are clear-cut, either good or bad, right or wrong. When reality presents conflicting information – when the person we admire shows a flaw, or the situation we idealized turns complicated – it creates a kind of mental static, an uncomfortable state known psychologically as cognitive dissonance. Our instinct is often to resolve this discomfort quickly. We might try to ignore the flaw, double down on the idealization, or, more commonly, swing dramatically to the other extreme: devaluation.

This swing is where the trouble often begins. Faced with the imperfection of a person, a relationship, a job, or even our own past (think of the common lament: "My parents weren't the ideal parents I wished for"), we don't just adjust our expectations; we sometimes discard the object of our disappointment entirely. The real person, the real situation, fails to match the flawless image we held, and so, in our hurt, we declare it worthless. The admired mentor makes a mistake, and suddenly their wisdom seems tainted. The beloved hobby becomes frustrating, and we abandon it. The relationship hits a rough patch, and we start scanning the horizon for someone "better," someone who fits the perfect mould we still carry in our minds.

Getting caught in this pattern – idealize, disappoint, devalue, repeat – keeps us perpetually searching, never truly landing, never truly learning to accept the world and the people in it as they are, in all their complex, contradictory glory. It's like being on a perpetual swing, moving between enchantment and disillusionment, always expecting perfection to arrive like manna from heaven, yet never finding it because it doesn’t exist in that pure form. Most people “swing” on these swings throughout their lives without even realizing it.

One of the most significant casualties of this cycle is gratitude. When we devalue something because it didn't meet our idealized expectations, we often become blind to the value it did offer, the good it did contain. We couldn't appreciate the imperfect parents for what they did provide because we were fixated on what they didn't. We can't acknowledge the lessons learned from a challenging job if we only focus on its frustrations. This inability to see and appreciate the partial good, the real value amidst the flaws, prevents us from truly receiving and integrating the gifts offered. We remain, in a sense, psychologically hungry, unable to take in nourishment because we're waiting for a perfect, mythical feast.

So, how do we step off this swing? How do we handle disappointment with dignity, allowing it to refine rather than shatter us? The key lies in moving towards a more integrated and differentiated view of reality. This sounds complex, but the essence is simple: learn to see the whole picture.

Differentiation means actively looking for the different facets of a person or situation. Instead of seeing someone as purely "good" or "bad," we make an effort to recognize their various traits, strengths, weaknesses, motivations, and inconsistencies. We acknowledge the nuances.

Integration is the next step: realizing and accepting that all these different, sometimes contradictory, parts coexist within the same person or situation. The admired colleague can be both brilliant and occasionally insensitive. Your parents could have made significant mistakes and loved you deeply in their own imperfect way. A job can be both rewarding and stressful.

Holding these complexities together, allowing for the coexistence of good and bad, light and shadow, is the foundation of maintaining dignity in the face of disappointment. It means we don't need to destroy the entire image just because one part is flawed. We can acknowledge the flaw, feel the disappointment, but still recognize the inherent worth. We see the person, or the situation, more realistically, more holistically. Those who know how to overcome these polarities grow and develop both in life and in their profession.

This process mirrors the work often done in personal growth and psychotherapy. We learn to look at ourselves with more nuance, accepting the parts of ourselves we might prefer to ignore or reject. As we build a more complex, multifaceted, and integrated image of our own self, we naturally become better equipped to see and accept the complexities in others. We begin to notice and accept other people who previously seemed ambiguous to us when our self-image becomes more differentiated and whole.

Disillusionment, then, isn't just an ending; it's a necessary passage. It marks the departure from the fairy tales of childhood, where things were simple and magic resided solely in external figures or perfect circumstances. Letting go of the illusion of a perfect world and perfect people can feel like a loss. But it’s also the threshold to growing up, to realizing that we ourselves can become the source of magic in our own, very real, adult lives. We step away from expecting perfection and start appreciating the unique, imperfect reality of people and the world around us.

Humans aren't perfect, and that is profoundly okay. We can spend our lives chasing an elusive ideal – the perfect partner, the perfect career, the perfect body, the perfect life – or we can choose to engage with the richness of reality. By accepting people as individuals, noticing their specific qualities (both the admirable and the difficult), and embracing the complexity of life, we begin to change the world we inhabit. And that change, inevitably, starts within each of us.

References:

  • Hayes, S. C., Strosahl, K. D., & Wilson, K. G. (2012). Acceptance and Commitment Therapy: The Process and Practice of Mindful Change (2nd ed.). Guilford Press.

    This book outlines Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), a therapeutic approach relevant to the article's call for acceptance. ACT principles encourage accepting difficult feelings like disappointment without being overwhelmed by them ("acceptance") and separating oneself from rigid expectations ("cognitive defusion"). This aligns with the article's message about accepting reality, acknowledging imperfection, and moving forward constructively rather than getting stuck in devaluation. (Chapters on Acceptance and Defusion, e.g., Chapters 5 & 7, are particularly pertinent).

You need to be logged in to send messages
Login Sign up
To create your specialist profile, please log in to your account.
Login Sign up
You need to be logged in to contact us
Login Sign up
To create a new Question, please log in or create an account
Login Sign up
Share on other sites

If you are considering psychotherapy but do not know where to start, a free initial consultation is the perfect first step. It will allow you to explore your options, ask questions, and feel more confident about taking the first step towards your well-being.

It is a 30-minute, completely free meeting with a Mental Health specialist that does not obligate you to anything.

What are the benefits of a free consultation?

Who is a free consultation suitable for?

Important:

Potential benefits of a free initial consultation

During this first session: potential clients have the chance to learn more about you and your approach before agreeing to work together.

Offering a free consultation will help you build trust with the client. It shows them that you want to give them a chance to make sure you are the right person to help them before they move forward. Additionally, you should also be confident that you can support your clients and that the client has problems that you can help them cope with. Also, you can avoid any ethical difficult situations about charging a client for a session in which you choose not to proceed based on fit.

We've found that people are more likely to proceed with therapy after a free consultation, as it lowers the barrier to starting the process. Many people starting therapy are apprehensive about the unknown, even if they've had sessions before. Our culture associates a "risk-free" mindset with free offers, helping people feel more comfortable during the initial conversation with a specialist.

Another key advantage for Specialist

Specialists offering free initial consultations will be featured prominently in our upcoming advertising campaign, giving you greater visibility.

It's important to note that the initial consultation differs from a typical therapy session:

No Internet Connection It seems you’ve lost your internet connection. Please refresh your page to try again. Your message has been sent